Standards: Where do they all belong

Have you heard this one? How many standards does it take to make a curriculum?

I don’t think anyone knows, but when it gets o murky that we have standard 3.25 A and Standard 3.25B and Standard 3.25C and D and E and  F and well you get the point. Anyone who thinks standards are the savoir of education should not be in education. In Philadelphia, depending on the principal you may have, lesson plans may require you to write the standards you are teaching to, the objectives of the lesson, and the strategies you will use. The superfluous information in there are the standards.

In today’s fixed curriculum where there is no imagination, creativity, originality, or room for a teacher to even introduce  something that might be high interest or current, standards may be of  use to curriculum developers, but not to teachers. The objective of the lesson already dictate what standards are being taught, so why create burdensome paperwork by demanding teachers type up standards on their lesson plans, and in many cases post them on their walls.

Want to improve education? Maximize the time Educators have to prepare lessons, review student work, and give students feedback. Just as misbehavior must be dealt with immediately for discipline to be effective, feedback must be timely for students to benefit. In a child centered classroom let’s insure we meet the needs of the child and not the needs or ego of the curriculum developer.

Standards have a place in education, but that place is not in the classroom: It’s in the curriculum developer’s office, and let’s leave it there.


2 thoughts on “Standards: Where do they all belong

  1. I sympathize with you in a couple respects, but I disagree with you in another.

    I sympathize with you in terms of how there should be a limit to how many standards that any given state should formulate. We can only keep track of so many academic standards in a single school year.

    I disagree with you when you say that standards have no place in the classroom. To clarify, my understanding was that the objectives that all lessons have are for satisfying particular state standards. In that way, state standards do have a place in the classroom (i.e. being tied to the objectives).

    I don’t necessarily think that all of those standards are significant, but I presume that at least some of them are. However, in this regard, I think all you were saying was that you shouldn’t have to plaster your walls with the standards that you need to satisfy. I agree with that.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s